Reviews

We’ve had the opportunity to work with Schaefer Custom Homes on a current custom home project on the Central Coast. As a designer, I’ve worked with residential custom home builders for 25+ years and I can say that Schaefer Custom Homes would be my first choice for future projects. Their unique approach to managing the front-end of what can be a daunting undertaking is refreshing and reassuring. Their extensive experience with custom home construction is evident in how they approach coordination, problem-solving, scheduling, and collaboration with the architectural and design team. I’m a strong believer in approaching the start of a project with as many details as possible ironed out before construction begins. This will always lead to a smoother construction process. The team at Schaefer Custom Homes clearly operates with a similar attention to detail and willingness to work collaboratively to ensure a well-considered and efficient project. I would definitely recommend Schaefer Custom Homes to anyone considering a custom home or remodeling project on the Central Coast.

I recently had the opportunity to sit down for coffee with Matthew Mitchell from Schaefer Custom Homes, and I walked away genuinely impressed. Matthew shared their approach to custom home building and remodeling, and what stood out to me was just how structured and thorough their process is. When you're investing in a custom home or major construction project, there are a lot of moving pieces and inevitably some uncertainty. Having a team that takes communication, quality and integrity seriously makes a huge difference. It was clear from my conversation with Matthew that those aren't just talking points for Schaefer Custom Homes—they've put real thought and process behind how they take care of their clients. I would highly recommend Schaefer Custom Homes to anyone considering a custom home, remodel or one of their other custom construction services. Quality and integrity matter in this industry, and Schaefer Custom Homes clearly takes both seriously.

Great Service! Can't say enough good things. Erich and Matt were very friendly and helpful. Highly

They are great to work with!

This is the second house my wife and I built so we had a pretty good understanding of the processes involved. We've now been in our new house for 2 years. Erich Schaefer and his team did an excellent job from start to finish. Was everything perfect? No, but the commitment to make sure there was follow-up on a problem and that it was taken care of is what makes a great GC. What impressed us was the "hands on" by Erich. He frequently stopped by the house at critical times. He even took half a day (a year after we moved in) to figure out our HVAC system so that it worked properly. He and his team were great to work with. Thank you Erich and team. We love our home.

As a trade partner, Viola Construction appreciates the opportunity to work with Schaefer Custom Homes on a recent ADU project. From our perspective, the project was organized, clearly communicated, and ran efficiently from start to finish. The Schaefer team provided a well-prepared site and maintained a steady workflow, allowing us to complete our portion of the work without delays or complications. Coordination with their team and other trades was seamless. Expectations were clear, communication was consistent, and they addressed any questions promptly, making the entire process straightforward and productive. Schaefer Custom Homes sets a high standard for professionalism and attention to detail, which is evident in how they manage projects in the field. We value the relationship and look forward to working together again on future projects.

Amazing home builder! Very detailed and thorough.

Our project included extensive exterior renovations, including removal and replacement of exterior siding, decks, exterior stairway, exterior doors, concrete and pathway replacement, painting, new roof and gutters, surface treatment of decks, and more. We found Schaefer's expertise to be exemplary and their services and prompt response to customer inquiries and requests very satisfying. Owner and project manager met with us several times at the property to review progress and offer advice. Overall, a very satisfactory and worthwhile contractor experience.

As a Civil Engineer working on multiple homes with Schaefer Custom Homes, I’ve seen firsthand how well they manage the custom home building process. Their team is highly organized, communicative, and collaborative with engineers, architects, and designers, something that’s critical on complex projects. Schaefer Custom Homes pays close attention to detail, respects engineered designs, and proactively addresses challenges, especially on high-end and coastal custom homes in San Luis Obispo County. Just as important, they communicate clearly with clients and consistently prioritize quality and long-term performance. I confidently recommend Schaefer Custom Homes to anyone looking for a trusted Central Coast custom home builder who values craftsmanship, professionalism, and teamwork.

As a real estate professional in San Luis Obispo, I’ve reviewed Schaefer Custom Homes’ building process and am consistently impressed by their professionalism, transparency, and quality of work. Their approach to custom home construction in San Luis Obispo County is well-organized and client-focused, with clear communication around timelines, budgets, and expectations. The craftsmanship and attention to detail are evident throughout their projects. I confidently recommend Schaefer Custom Homes to clients seeking a trusted San Luis Obispo custom home builder known for integrity and exceptional results.